Capital One Quicksilver Student vs Surge Platinum Mastercard: Which Is Better In 2026?

Surge® Platinum Mastercard® Breakdown

‍

[[ SINGLE_CARD * {"id": "2249", "isExpanded": "false", "bestForCategoryId": "52", "bestForText": "Boosting Your Credit Score", "headerHint" : "Credit Builder" } ]]

‍

Why We Like It

‍

Here is a breakdown of why we like the Surge® Platinum Mastercard®.

‍

• As an unsecured card, it does not require a security deposit, which keeps your cash available for other needs.
• It is accessible to applicants with poor or no credit history, offering a pathway to establishing a positive payment record.
• Your payment activity is reported to all three major credit bureaus, which can help improve your credit over time with responsible use.

‍

‍

Pros

‍

• You can check for pre-qualification without an initial inquiry that affects your credit score.
• Your account is automatically reviewed for a credit limit increase after a history of on-time payments.
• Includes zero fraud liability protection against unauthorized charges.

‍

Cons

‍

• Carries high annual and monthly fees that make it an expensive option for building credit.
• Offers no rewards program, sign-up bonus, or other significant perks to offset its costs.
• Lacks an upgrade path to a better card, and its fee structure can make it challenging to maintain a low credit utilization ratio.

Surge® Platinum Mastercard® vs Capital One Quicksilver Student Cash Rewards

‍

Categories

‍

When deciding which is better, Capital One Quicksilver Student or Surge Platinum Mastercard, it's crucial to understand their primary purposes, as each card serves a very different audience and financial goal.

‍

• Capital One Quicksilver Student Cash Rewards This card is best for students looking to build credit while earning straightforward rewards. It’s designed for those with limited credit who want a simple card without tracking complex categories.
• Surge® Platinum Mastercard® This card is categorized as a tool for individuals with poor or no credit who need to build or rebuild their credit file. It's intended for those who may not qualify for other types of credit cards.

‍

Redemption

‍

Capital One Quicksilver Student Cash Rewards: This card offers flexible cash back redemption options, allowing cardholders to receive their earnings in various ways. You can typically redeem your cash back for a statement credit or a check.

‍

Surge® Platinum Mastercard®: As a card focused on building or rebuilding credit, it does not offer a rewards program. Therefore, there are no points or cash back to redeem.

‍

Compare Top Rated Credit Cards with Kudos

‍

Kudos is a financial companion that helps you compare nearly 3,000 credit cards, providing data-driven recommendations to find the best card for your unique spending patterns.

‍

• Test drive credit cards: Before you apply, you can simulate how much you would earn with a specific credit card based on your actual spending data.
• $100 Kudos Kickstart+: You can unlock $100 in Kickstart+ Rewards by adding select approved cards to your Kudos Wallet.
• Welcome offer guarantee: If you find a better offer for a card within three months of being approved, Kudos will match it.
• Detailed approval odds: Get a comprehensive analysis of your approval chances based on your credit report.
• Kudos Boost rewards: Earn additional rewards on top of your credit card rewards when shopping at your favorite stores.
• Personalized tracking: Monitor your transactions, spending, and credit score while also tracking your credit card perks.

Who Should Choose the Capital One Quicksilver Student Cash Rewards?

‍

The Capital One Quicksilver Student Cash Rewards Credit Card is an excellent choice for students who are just starting to build their credit history and want a simple, no-fuss rewards card. Its unlimited 1.5% cash back on all purchases and no annual fee make it a low-maintenance option for managing everyday expenses. The card is particularly beneficial for international students or those who study abroad, thanks to its lack of foreign transaction fees and 5% cash back on hotels and rental cars booked through Capital One Travel.

Who Should Choose the Surge® Platinum Mastercard®?

‍

The Surge® Platinum Mastercard® is designed for individuals with poor or limited credit history, particularly those with scores below 600 who have been rejected by other lenders. This card serves as a last-resort option for people who cannot afford the security deposit required for a secured card but need immediate access to an unsecured line of credit. The ideal user will leverage this card as a short-term tool to establish a record of on-time payments with all three credit bureaus before graduating to a card with lower fees and better benefits.

Alternatives to Consider

‍

So, the Capital One Quicksilver Student vs Surge Platinum Mastercard comparison didn't leave you with a clear choice? No problem—plenty of other cards can help you build your credit history.

‍

[[ COMPARE_CARD * {"ids": ["509", "118"], "bestCategoryIds":["17", "18", "19"], "bestForTexts":["Exceptional Value", "Generous Travel Rewards"]} ]]

‍

_{Terms apply to American Express benefits and offers. Enrollment may be required for select American Express benefits and offers. Visit americanexpress.com to learn more. Eligibility and Benefit level varies by Card. Terms, Conditions, and Limitations Apply. Please visit americanexpress.com/benefitsguide for more details. Underwritten by Amex Assurance Company.}

‍

Tips for Application Success

‍

Before You Apply

‍

• Check Your Credit Score: Ensure your credit profile aligns with the card's requirements, whether it's for excellent, fair, or rebuilding credit.
• Gather Your Documents: Have your personal information, income details, and any required documentation like student verification ready.
• Define Your Goal: Know if you're applying to earn rewards, build credit as a student, or rebuild your financial standing.

‍

Application Strategy

‍

• Use Pre-qualification Tools: Check your approval odds without impacting your credit score when this option is available.
• Be Honest and Accurate: Provide truthful information, especially for income or student status, to avoid application delays or denials.
• Don't Be Discouraged: If you are denied, consider other cards tailored to your specific credit profile and needs.

Our Methodology

‍

We evaluate nearly 3,000 credit cards across the U.S. market — far more than the ~150 cards commonly featured on sites that focus only on products tied to affiliate commissions. Our goal is to provide a comprehensive, unbiased view of the credit card landscape so you can make confident, data-driven decisions.

‍

Our editorial team combines deep industry experience with rigorous verification standards. While our experts surface the most relevant recommendations in our guides, you can also explore the full dataset yourself through our card explorer tool, which includes thousands of cards — more than 95% of which do not provide us with commissions.

Frequently Asked Questions

‍

Which card is better for building credit from scratch?

‍

The Capital One Quicksilver Student card is designed for students with limited or no credit history, making it an excellent choice for building credit. While the Surge Platinum Mastercard can also help rebuild credit, the student card is often a better starting point for those with no credit history at all.

‍

Are there annual fees for the Quicksilver Student or Surge Platinum card?

‍

Typically, the Capital One Quicksilver Student card does not have an annual fee, which is a common feature for student credit cards. The Surge Platinum Mastercard, however, is geared toward those with poor credit and often includes an annual fee.

‍

Can I apply for the Capital One Quicksilver Student card if I'm not a student?

‍

To be eligible for the Capital One Quicksilver Student card, you generally must be enrolled at a college or university. If you are not a student, you would need to consider other credit cards that do not have this requirement.

‍

‍